Movie: Bluebeard
My Rating: 4 stars
This is a surprisingly interesting film—charming and disturbing at the same time. It’s a delightfully old-fashioned fairy tale—the kind you don’t really see any more. It seems like these days, everyone’s interested in reinterpreting fairy tales into sassy, tales full of ironic humor, and empowered female leads. But, this one’s different. Or, should I say traditional? It’s very old-school. The story is set in the very bleak Old Europe, with poverty and malnutrition. Elderly widowers marry eleven-year-old brides, and these girls are ok with the arrangement because it’s better than starving to death. Heck, our little heroine is just thrilled just to be getting the first new dress she’s ever had. You just don’t see this stuff anymore.
The Bluebeard story is an old classic, but a lot of people aren’t familiar with it anymore. The story has fallen out of favor lately since it’s one of the more barbaric of the old-style stories. A wealthy lord marries young, local girls, but his brides always seem to go missing after a short time. We get a glimpse of what has been going on when he marries the main female character, an 11-year-old girl, Marie-Catherine, whose family is thrown into poverty when her father, the main bread-winner, dies suddenly. Bluebeard is charmed by the girl’s innocence. In fact, he seems obsessed by it. He gives her full reign of his castle, and hands over all the keys, telling her that he knows he can trust her. But, he tells her that there is one door that she is never to go into. He then promptly leaves on a “business trip.” As we might expect, the very first thing our little lass does when he leaves is run to open up that door. There, she finds the corpses of all Bluebeard’s previous wives. Turns out, they’d all gotten too uppity, and peeked into the room after he’d told them not to. Bluebeard learns of their untrustworthy nature, of course, by returning “early” from his business trip. And, now he can’t even trust little Marie-Catherine—the most “innocent” of all his wives! He decides that she must be put to death as well. It’s pretty bleak. What could have been the purpose of such a story? To teach young brides to be obedient? I can see why people might be reluctant to read this old story to their children—or at least why it doesn’t seem very relevant today.
The film is presented in the recognizable format of two little girls reading a scary, old, fairy tale book in the attic. Their mother has told them not to, because they always end up crying when they get scared. But, I’m not really sure why the story was framed this way. The Bluebeard story seems to work pretty well on it’s own, and the two, little readers don’t really add that much to the story. I guess it could be a commentary on how the nature of children’s tales have changed. We don’t really read these stark, bloody tales to kids anymore. Or, it could serve to highlight the difference between the quality of life in the Middle Ages versus now. The sisters in the fairy tale have to face the hard realities of life and from a very young age. Their mother thrusts them into the adult world, where they’ll have to earn their keep through marriage. But, our modern-day sisters are allowed to stay little girls, reading stories and drinking milk. On second thought, perhaps that’s exactly the purpose of this format. Maybe it’s attempting to show just why this old story is no longer relevant—why little girls have to sneak up into the attic to read it, even though they give themselves nightmares every time they do. The contrast between two sets of girls, each sneaking into forbidden rooms in the house, couldn’t be more dramatic. This is a funny sort of movie. It’s far different in tone from anything I’ve seen before—deliberate and bleak, yet seen through innocent eyes. But, I think it’s definitely worthwhile.






































